APPRECIATION
TheStar.com | Entertainment | The world just got a lot less irreverent
The world just got a lot less irreverent
AP FILE PHOTO/FOX BROADCASTING CO.
George Carlins staunch defence of free speech went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. Carlin, seen here in a 1993 file photo, died June 22, 2008.
Email Story
Report Typo
AddThis

 

Carlin ruled indecent, but he liked it that way 

George Carlin made history.

During a show in 1972, Carlin recited one of his most famous – or infamous, depending on your perspective – routines, known as "Dirty Words" a.k.a. "Seven Words You Can Never Say On Television" (note: you can't say them in a newspaper like this one, either).

Uttering those words led to Carlin's arrest, but a U.S. judge, citing constitutional free speech rights, dismissed the charges. When the routine was aired on an East Coast radio station, the U.S. Federal Communications Commission took action against the broadcaster in a case that went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, which in 1978 ruled the words were indecent but not obscene.

The court also upheld the commission's right to regulate radio and television broadcasts during the hours when children might be tuning in, creating a 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. blanket ban against those words that stands to this day.

Last June, a U.S. federal court dismissed an FCC complaint against the Fox TV network for the airing of the f-word, resulting in a suspension of the commission's crackdown on profanity.

As a result of a previous Supreme Court decision, cable and satellite broadcasters, which charge special fees for access, are not subject to the same level of scrutiny and enforcement as public broadcasters, which are considered to be of a "uniquely pervasive nature."

Carlin acknowledged a certain pride in the controversy.

"So my name is a footnote in American legal history, which I'm perversely kind of proud of," he told the Associated Press.

The Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission allows a little more leeway when it comes to loose language on our airwaves.

Bruce DeMara


George Carlin put bite into the staid world of standup comedy
Jun 24, 2008 04:30 AM

Entertainment Reporter

George Carlin began his career in comedy as a jacket and tie kind of guy, with a partner.

But after shedding his partner, Jack Burns, in the early '60s, and donning a beard, ponytail and the casual hippy garb of the time, Carlin went on to redefine standup comedy, shatter taboos, and redefine obscenity and indecency when his "dirty words" routine sparked a case that went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Carlin, 71, died in Los Angeles of heart failure Sunday, days after learning he would receive the Kennedy Center Honors and the Mark Twain Prize for American Humor.

In the past, those receiving the Kennedy Center award have been expected to attend the ceremony, but, in a break from tradition, officials announced the event would proceed as planned on Nov. 20.

Yesterday, comics paid tribute to his indispensable contribution to standup and humour.

"Carlin was a huge influence on comedians, and comedy in general, but it went beyond that," said Brent Butt, star of CTV's Corner Gas.

"He was one of those rare commentators, like court jesters in medieval England, who could use comedy and satire to actually influence the fabric of the culture.

"At his best, he had policy-makers and trendsetters in every industry taking note. That may have been a good thing or a bad thing, depending on your politics, but no one can deny it was happening," Butt added.

American shock comic Sandra Bernhard, in Toronto for Pride Week festivities and for an appearance on eTalk, called Carlin's passing "a sad end to an era. George was a trailblazer politically and a true original, and he will be deeply missed."

Carlin, born May 12, 1937, was a high school dropout raised by a single mother in the Morningside Heights section of Manhattan. He began his career in the U.S. Air Force as an off-base disc jockey in Shreveport, La.

He moved on to another deejay job in Fort Worth, Tex., and stints as a carnival organist and marketing director for peanut brittle, before he and radio buddy Burns got their first break when they appeared on Jack Paar's Tonight Show.

Mark Breslin, founder of the Yuk Yuk's chain of comedy clubs, rated Carlin, along with Woody Allen and Richard Pryor, among the greatest comics of the late 20th century.

"I don't think there would be a Bill Maher today, a Jon Stewart or a Dennis Miller, without George Carlin. George Carlin kicked open the taboos for all those people and more, and so many comics working nightly in comedy clubs," Breslin said.

But Carlin was more than a buffoon in Breslin's estimation; he was a social satirist of keen intelligence.

"(Carlin) was a very smart guy and his comedy was smart. There was nothing silly or stupid about his comedy at any point

"He wasn't a comic who made a career out of movies ... (or) of sitcoms. He made a career the old-fashioned way: by getting up in front of people and telling the truth in a funny way." Breslin also recalled Carlin "was very good about spending time with young comics and giving them advice and helping them out."

"I would always go backstage whenever I would see him, here or in the States, and there was always a little lineup of comics waiting to meet him and talk to him, and he always had time for them. You know, that's a generous person."

Toronto-born comic Brian Lazanik called Carlin a true inspiration.

"He's only the reason I got into standup. He's only the reason everybody does (standup comedy) today. Everything we think of standup today, he's responsible for 80 per cent of it."

"He transcended the generations; that was the amazing thing," U.S. comedian Robert Klein said. "He was the universal American comedian. A counterculture Bob Hope but not quite counterculture."

"Nobody was funnier than George Carlin," said Judd Apatow, director of hit comedies such as Knocked Up and The 40-Year-Old Virgin.

Toronto-based comic Trevor Boris described Carlin as "definitely one of the prolific comics of all time," citing his 23 comedy albums, 14 HBO specials and his 130 appearances on The Tonight Show.

"I'm pretty young and the people I look up to are maybe a little bit more contemporary, but those people were all influenced by George Carlin ... he's the starting point."

With files from AP, Los Angeles Times

Advertisement
Advertisement
SPECIAL
You followed him last year while he quit smoking. Now David Bruser is back with a new goal: get in shape. Read his fitness blog and ...
It becomes obvious, as the hotel door swings open into a wall of tobacco smoke, that Burton Cummings has not held onto that ...
Clayton Preddy would like it if you got your own bike this winter. Just because yours doesn't have an indestructible polyurethane ...
Apples, fish and breastfeeding. According to studies released this week, these three things can keep babies from developing asthma, ...
Michael Sacco is interrupted by the root-canal screech of an electric saw. Upstairs, a crew is readying the next phase of his business ...